Gerard Henderson’s Media Watch Dog
ISSUE – NO. 799
04 November 2026
****
Stop Press – The supposedly cash-strapped ABC sends a small army of reporters to the US to cover on the midterm elections; Faruqi-Hanson round 3 to be heard in the High Court
Can You Bear It? Sally Sara goes soft on Jim Chalmers; A look back at David Marr’s concern that Donald Trump would call off the midterm elections; Jane Caro’s pre-election freakout
Media (Lunch) Watch – The Age pays for Michael Kirby’s biscuit
An ABC Update – The ABC puts out the begging bowl to fund future “investments”
History Corner – Judith Brett’s embrace of David Day’s bizarre theory that Robert Menzies conspired to install himself as Winston Churchill’s successor
****
The Latest
Stacks on the ABC mill in reporting the US midterm elections
As avid Media Watch Dog readers know, the taxpayer funded public broadcaster is invariably crying poor and/or begging for more money. See this week’s “An ABC Update” for example.
It is noticeable, however, that there is never a shortage of funds when it comes to sending ABC management’s fave journalists overseas.
Take, for example, the United States midterm elections. The ABC recently promoted John Lyons to the position of America’s editor. According to MWD’s count, the ABC has the following reporting from its Washington DC office – John Lyons, Lauren Day, and Kamin Gock.
However, the ABC management felt the need to send re-enforcements. So 7.30’s Sarah Ferguson and Adam Harvey, plus Jade McMillan’s international unit, plus Four Corners reporter Mark Willacy plus Europe Correspondent Elias Clure. Moreover, the Radio National Hour’s Fran Kelly has been in New York – but she may not be on an ABC task.
MWD will examine the ABC’s midterm reporting next week. But an early examination indicated that Comrade Ferguson’s interviews could well have been conducted from her home base in Sydney. For a broadcaster which is invariably complaining about shortage of funds, all this seems like an indulgence.

Sarah Ferguson in Washington DC, conducting an interview with Anthony Scaramucci while he sits in a London office. Scaramucci worked for the Trump administration for 10 days in 2017.
Round 3 in the Faruqi-Hanson media fight
This is what Sydney Morning Herald columnist Jacqueline Maley noted in the “Final Observation” segment in last Sunday’s ABC TV Insiders program:
Jacqueline Maley: We’ll probably hear from the High Court this week about whether or not they’re going to hear the appeal from Senator Hanson in her defamation case against Mehreen Faruqi. So, if they do decide to hear it, this is a sort of really interesting freedom of speech issue that will no doubt be politicised, no matter what the sort of result is. And it’s part of a few cases that are going before the High Court at the moment about this implied freedom of political communication that we do have in our Constitution. But it’s sort of not settled how the freedom applies in these very sort of fervid and divisive times in which we live. So that’s a really interesting one to watch.
Interesting, eh? But perhaps a bit more complicated than Comrade Maley implied. Ellies’s (male) co-owner was present some decades ago when a High Court Justice was asked: “Where can I find an implied freedom of free speech in the Constitution?” The answer was “You cannot – because it’s implied.”
At the time, this sounded like a line out of Alice in Wonderland. In any event, the implied freedom concept prevailed.
The High Court of Australia decided on 5 November that it would hear One Nation Leader Senator Pauline Hanson’s appeal against the decision that she had breached the Racial Discrimination Act with respect to comments she made about the Greens Senator Mehreen Faruqi.
The background is well described by James Dowling and Elizabeth Pike in The Australian on 6 November. To put it simply, the Pakistan-born Faruqi criticised Queen Elizabeth, who happened to be the Queen of Australia, when she died in September 2022. Faruqi declared that Queen Elizabeth was the leader of “a racist empire built on stolen lives, land and wealth of colonised people”. A fiery comment indeed.
To which Hanson replied that Faruqi has chosen to live in Australia and added: “It’s clear you’re not happy, so pack your bags and piss off back to Pakistan”. A fiery response, indeed.
The Federal Court decided that the verbal exchange between these senators had resulted in Hanson using a “racist trope”. The decision was upheld by the full court of the Federal Court. And now it to be examined by the full court of the High Court.
In time, we will learn whether there is, in Jacqueline Maley’s words, an implied right to freedom of speech in the Constitution. And, perhaps, how to find it – and whether it prevails on occasions of fiery political exchanges. MWD will keep readers posted – as the saying goes.
Can You Bear It?
Sally Sara’s soft interview with Treasurer Jim Chalmers
On Tuesday 3 November, The Australian led with a story by Matthew Cranston titled “Money Monster: Chalmers secret $170bn spending costs abyss”. The lead was as follows:
“A $170bn black hole discovered in Labor’s federal budget has sparked serious concern government spending and costs are blowing out by more than previously thought, fuelling inflation and likely triggering the fifth rate hike of the year at Tuesday’s Reserve Bank meeting.”
This was no opposition inspired beat-up. Indeed at 2.08 am on 3 November, after reading Cranston’s report in The Australian Online, independent and respected economist Chris Richardson issued a post which commenced “An Extra $170B? – We Should Have Been Told About That”.
It so happened that ABC Radio National Breakfast had arranged for Sally Sara to interview Treasurer Jim Chalmers that very morning. In the follow-up transcript, the Treasurer’s Office described the subjects discussed as “Housing market, Interest rates, Superannuation standards, US midterm elections”.
Hang on a minute. Sally Sara did not raise with the Treasurer the issue of the alleged black hole in the May 2026 budget. Nor did she mention that, on the same day, the Australian Financial Review had led with a story that the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) had failed to convince Treasury’s top actuary that it can reduce costs of the NDIS by $38.2 billion over the next four years. This suggested another “black hole” in the 2026 budget.
So, what did Comrade Sara do? Well, she threw the switch to oh-so-softness and avoided the big issues of the day for which her guest was accountable. Let’s go to the transcript where the interview commenced:
Sally Sara: Jim Chalmers is the federal Treasurer and joins me now. Treasurer, welcome back to the program.
Jim Chalmers: Thanks very much, Sally. How are you?
Sally Sara: Very well, thank you. Are property prices falling further than you anticipated?
Jim Chalmers: There’s certainly been a lot of volatility in the housing market that began before the Budget…
And so it continued. Sara did not ask Chalmers about The Australian or AFR stories. Moreover, she made no attempt to hold the Treasurer to account concerning his own budget. This contrasts with her, often confronting, interviews with Coalition shadow ministers. Can You Bear It?
[No, not really. Now that you ask. Perhaps you should have held this off for a couple of weeks and awarded Comrade Sara your prestigious “Softest Interview of the Month” gong. Just a thought. – MWD Editor.]
David Marr’s fear that President Trump would stop the US mid-term elections came to naught
Last week the free elections in Israel demonstrated, if demonstration was necessary, that Israel is not an apartheid state intent on genocide. Arabs make up around 20 per cent of the Israeli population and the Arab vote had a significant outcome on the election. If Israel was an apartheid state, there would be no representation for Arabs in the Israeli parliament. And if it was into genocide there would be no Palestinians in Israel or Gaza.
The same is true of the United States midterm elections. Clearly Republican President Donald Trump is not, as alleged by many leftists, a fascist ruler. Since, in a free election, there was a blue (i.e. Democratic) wave across both the House of Representatives and Senate elections. Fascists don’t permit free elections.
It is timely to recall that, not so long ago, some commentators were predicting that Trump was so undemocratic that he would not allow free elections in the US midterms – due to the fact that his approval in the polls was disastrously low.
So, Let’s go to the transcript of ABC Radio National, Late Night Live (aka Late Night Left) on 10 March this year where the following exchange took place between presenter David Marr and American left-wing commentator Bruce Shapiro who is a regular commentator on LNL.
Bruce Shapiro: There is nothing this low in the history of polling. And that is weighing tremendously on on the White House as it goes forward.
David Marr: Is, is the fact that the White House is worried about the electoral impact of this war, reassuring evidence that there will be midterm elections. I mean, are you absolutely confident that he [President Trump] will hold midterm elections?
Bruce Shapiro: Well, you know, it’s not up to the president to hold elections. We still do have a constitution….
So, there you have it. In March David Marr wondered aloud if President Trump would cancel the 2026 midterm elections to be held in November. How neurotic can a sufferer of Trump Derangement Syndrome get? Can You Bear It?
Leftist influencer Jane Caro warned of a Trump victory before the US mid-term polls opened
While on the topic of Trump Derangement Syndrome, the delusion continued on in Australia until Tuesday morning (which was Monday evening in Washington DC). Leftist commentator Jane Caro put out this fanatic post at 10.45 am (AEDT) on Tuesday 3 November:
This had received 440,000 views by 10.30 am (AEDT) on Tuesday, but proved to be hopelessly wrong.
The advice “Have a Bex and a lie down” has gone out of fashion these days. But it was wise counsel, nevertheless, which could have been beneficial to Comrade Caro. However, Media Watch Dog needs content producers like Caro, who is much loved by the ABC and Nine Entertainment newspapers. So, perhaps, it’s best to suffer Caro-rage.
As to the United States as a “terrifying place” refrain. Why is it that literally millions of foreigners want to become Americans every year. And here’s another question: Can You Bear It?
Media (Lunch) Watch – Michael Kirby AC CMG takes the biscuit at the Age/SMH lunch with Cara Waters
Avid Media Watch Dog readers just loved last week’s issue which contained the inaugural “Media Lunch Watch” segment. As readers will recall, comment was made on Nine Newspapers lunch event – when Stephen Brook reported on his recent lunch with Melbourne socialite and horse whisperer Ann Peacock.
Attention was given to Mr Brook’s culinary knowledge. Including his account of “the enticing entrée special, zucchini flower stuffed with scallops, mascarpone and crab grated bottarga on top”. Which, alas, he was not able to consume due to “dietaries”
In any event, the bill came to $240.50 including a $1 donation to charity. As MWD understands, this is automatically on the bill at Melbourne CBD’s Grill Americano and is charged unless rejected.
Compare and contrast last Saturday’s “Lunch With” feature in The Age and Sydney Morning Herald. Former High Court judge and light-eater, Michael Kirby (AC, CMG) was the guest. And Cara Waters (The Age’s city editor) was the interviewer. Now, let’s go to “The Bill Please” moment.
The Bill Please
Sausage roll $12
Golden Oat Cookie $6
Mocha $7
Long Black $5
Total $30
Streat
68 Cromwell Street
Collingwood
It turned out that the former judge said that he had already eaten a pescetarian-style meal on the plane to Melbourne. So he settled for a “mocha and biscuit”. While Cara Waters – a member of the Michael Kirby Fan Club – orders a spinach and ricotta roll.
Ms Waters declares: “The pastry is buttery and flaky and the creamy ricotta has a salty tang to it”. Frightfully interesting, to be sure. But somewhat south of Stephen Brook when it comes to culinary analysis, don’t you think?
It turns out that Mr Kirby chose the Streat café in inner-city Melbourne’s Collingwood (not far from Sandalista Central in nearby Fitzroy North). According to Ms Waters “it’s a social enterprise which provides vocational training and support programs for disadvantaged and homeless youth”.
A good cause. It’s just that a payment of a mere $30 from Nine Entertainment is unlikely to make much of a difference to the good work of Streat. Perhaps Nine could have added $1 for charity.
No doubt MWD readers would like to know that, according to The Age reporter, “Our lunch is over and Kirby carefully places the remainder of his biscuit in a paper to take away for later.”

Lunch for two at Nine’s “Lunch With”
[Perhaps you should remind avid readers that Michael Kirby spoke about his recently published collected speeches at The Sydney Institute on 25 May 2026. MWD Editor.]
An ABC Update – The ABC Goes Begging To Canberra With Requests For More Taxpayers’ Money For Unspecified Future “Investments”.
The ABC Annual Report 2025-26 was tabled in the House of Representatives on 26 October. That is, at a time when the Australian economy is in considerable difficulties with high inflation, increasing interest rates, growing unemployment and concern about the level of government spending – along with ever-rising energy prices.
The report was signed off by ABC chair Kim Williams. It contained a foreword by Williams along with an introduction by ABC Managing Director and editor-in-chief Hugh Marks. Here is the final paragraph of that part of the report titled “The Year Ahead”:
“During the coming year, the ABC will begin discussions with the Government about its level of funding in the next five-year period, which will begin in 2028. Starting these conversations before the current term is complete will support longer-term planning that would not be possible if the Corporation were to learn of its funding on the cusp of the next five years. The ABC anticipates making a compelling argument for further investment in its role as the media service for all Australians.
Hugh Marks
Managing Director,
Australian Broadcasting Corporation”
How about that? The ABC is hopelessly out of touch. With the Albanese government under increasing pressure to bring about net savings, Mr Marks wants the ABC to receive even more taxpayers’ money in 2028 and beyond for unspecified programs — which he terms “investments”.
Such an application would be laughed at when Mr Marks ran Nine Entertainment’s Network Nine plus such newspapers as The Age and Sydney Morning Herald. In those days of old, raising revenue meant providing content which attracted advertising or lending.
In his new role, attaining money means travelling to Canberra with empty buckets from ABC headquarters in inner-city Sydney and loading them with lotsa moolah provided by taxpayers. Outside of the ABC Bubble, such actions would be described as begging.
Mr Marks led off his upper-class panhandling in his “The year ahead” piece with the oh-so-familiar ABC refrain, namely: “The ABC remains Australia’s most trusted media brand and the leading source of news….”
A good begging line, to be sure. But it does not explain why, in the evening TV News bulletins, the taxpayer funded public broadcaster finishes third – behind Network Seven and Network Nine. Which means that your man Marks believes that Australians are so stupid that they watch news bulletins which they trust least (Networks 7 and 9). Rather than the one they trust most (i.e. ABC).
While the ABC remains a Conservative Free Zone – without a conservative presenter, producer or editor for any of its main news and current affairs programs – the ABC does not deserve even more taxpayers’ money. This would be better spent in, say, creating latrines in military camps.

The ABC managing director Hugh Marks at the National Press Club – as presented in the ABC 2025-2026 Annual Report, which is essentially a pitch for yet more taxpayers’ money.
History Corner – How Judith Brett once embraced David Day’s (fact-free) claim that Robert Menzies wanted to replace Winston Churchill as Britain’s prime minister in 1941
There was enormous interest in last week’s “History Corner”. It examined the claim that the Melbourne-based Judith Brett is “arguably the pre-eminent historian of the Liberal Party”.
Now Dr Brett (for a doctor she is) is best known for her 1992 book Robert Menzies’ Forgotten People. It is neither a Liberal Party history nor a Menzies biography. But, rather, a psychological account of the Liberal Party’s founder’s needs and actions based on reading some of his early speeches.
But there is another matter beyond the Freudian stuff. In Robert Menzies’ Forgotten People, Judith (“please call me ‘doctor’ except in a medical emergency”) Brett embraced the view about Menzies of fellow Melbourne-based left-wing historian David Day. This is what Comrade Brett wrote about what Comrade Day wrote about Menzies and Churchill when Menzies visited Britain in 1941:
“Menzies lobbied hard for some form of permanent Dominion representation on the British war cabinet, and for the inclusion of someone on the cabinet prepared to stand up to Churchill.20 These were both roles he felt he would fill admirably, the first as a prelude to the second. Day suggests that the position of Australian representative on the war cabinet was to be the Trojan Horse whereby Menzies could get within Churchill’s citadel to launch a direct attack against him. There was no obvious successor to Churchill, and Menzies expected that once he was a permanent member of the war cabinet he would rapidly become the heir apparent, ready to take over when the war took a turn for the worse and Churchill fell.
While these ambitions left little trace on the public record, contemporary observers, both in London and Canberra, recognised them and acknowledged they were possible. Again Menzies’ ambitions worked in tandem with his ideals in his challenge to a political superior; in taking on Churchill he was both protecting his beloved Empire and advancing himself.”
As MWD has pointed out for eons, this claim is absolute tosh. The idea that that when Britain was at war with Nazi Germany in 1941, it could not find a leader – and, consequently, needed to look to the Dominions – that is, the one-time colonies for a prime minister, is bunkum. As is the suggestion that Menzies was so naïve that he believed he could replace Churchill.
The only source cited by Brett for this assertion (i.e. footnote 20) is to David Day’s Menzies and Churchill at War.
Day’s theory that Menzies wanted to, and expected to, replace Churchill as prime minister has been demolished by Anne Henderson in her book Menzies at War (NewSouth, 2014) and in her article “Day-dreaming about Menzies in Wartime London” (Quadrant, March 2015).
Dr Brett concedes that Menzies’ “ambitions left little trace on the public record”. That’s hardly surprising since Day’s claim is not supported by any evidence. There is no source to support the Day/Brett theory. None whatsoever. It’s (history’s) fake news – to use a cliché.
David Day’s Menzies/Churchill thesis was dismissed in passing in 1993 by Professor Allan Martin in Robert Menzies: A Life as well as by Gerard Henderson in his 1994 book Menzies’ Child: The Liberal Party of Australia.
Then after extensive research, Anne Henderson totally demolished David Day’s Menzies/Churchill theory in her book Menzies at War which was published in July 2014. It was short-listed for the Prime Minister’s Literary Awards in 2015.
Following a rant by Dr Day (for a doctor he is) on this issue against Anne Henderson, the late Allan Martin and Gerard Henderson in The Spectator Australia in August 2014, Gerard Henderson wrote to your man Day on 4 August 2014. He asked the learned doctor to provide the name of one historian of 20th Century Britain – or one biographer of Winston Churchill – who wrote or said that Robert Menzies was considered suitable by the powers-that-be at Whitehall to replace Winston Churchill as prime minister of Britain in 1941. Just one. Along with any evidence that Menzies himself believed that this was possible.
On 4 August 2014, David Day emailed Gerard Henderson and claimed that he was “flat out like a lizard drinking at the moment” but would be “happy to respond” with the requested documentary evidence when he had the “time to do so”.
Gerard Henderson wrote to David Day again on 28 March 2017 to check whether he was still “flat out like a lizard drinking” and still not able to document the Menzies/Churchill assertion which first appeared in his successful Ph.D. thesis. Your man Day must have had a mighty thirst – because, over a decade later, he has not provided the promised evidence.
In March 2015, Anne Henderson’s article “Day-Dreaming about Menzies in Wartime London” was published in Quadrant. She went through every claim that Day made in Menzies & Churchill at War about Menzies wanting to succeed Churchill and checked the evidence in support. Anne Henderson also documented that many of Day’s conclusions were preceded by such words as may and maybe.
Also, as Anne Henderson pointed out, even Day concluded that there were “very few traces” of evidence that Menzies attempted to replace Churchill in 10 Downing Street. In fact, there were no evidential traces at all.
Yet Judith Brett has not acknowledged her error in believing Day’s thesis.
Media Watch Dog will publish an article by David Day providing, at long last, the evidence he claims to possess in support of his Menzies/Churchill thesis. Here’s hoping Comrade Day is not still in flat-out-like-a-lizard-drinking mode. MWD will let avid readers know.
*****
Until next time.
*****